Blogs | de Groots Best Restaurants of Australia
Blog

Fine Dining – are we getting what we pay for?

Date Posted: 18-10-2007

This topic was suggested by a Best Restaurants user, and I think it’s a really interesting question. I’d love to hear whether people think that fine dining is worth the cost. A few months ago the Sydney Morning Herald reviewed a $1000 degustation at Astral restaurant (awarded one chef’s toque and Chef of the Year in the 2008 SMH Good Food Guide). It’s a five hour, ten course study in luxury items such as French champagne, Petrossian caviar, lobster, truffles and Wagyu. The verdict – good, but not $1000 per head good. (Meanwhile, how much do you want Simon Thomsen’s job?) So what are we paying for when we order $50 mains and a bottle of wine for a couple of hundred bucks? Expensive, imported and rare ingredients; time and labour; impeccable service; perhaps a view? I think part of what we pay for is also the simple privilege of exclusivity, of joining a select group of people that have had some of the country’s most talented chefs cook for us. A “special occasion” restaurant would hardly be special if you could afford to dine there regularly. Nor would you experience the same sense of thrill and privilege at securing a booking somewhere, if it wasn’t difficult to arrange. All of this adds to the experience and mystique of fine dining, but the question remains – is it worth it?

Posted by: de Groots.

 

Jackie McMillan said...

I think there is a limit to how much I will pay and still feel I am getting value for money. We recently dined at Foveaux Restaurant and Bar, and did the 9 course degustation menu for $100 per head. The value for money here was extraordinary - especially when you consider how much work went into each dish. (Read my post about it here: http://missdissent.livejournal.com/110120.html)

One of the nice things about October is the chance to eat in some of the top end restaurants for less money with the special offers of Good Food Month. This is how I first tried Guillaume at Bennelong. Gourmet Traveler also has reader dinners which offer a similar type of discounted method of trying fine dining restaurants - I used this method to try Aria and Quay. Tabou which can be expensive ala carte, advertise special menus in Good Living from time to time (for example in October you can enjoy a 5 course Duck Degustation every evening for $68 per person).

I think there are ways of getting good value at fine dining restaurants. One suggestion I have is if you like degustations, always check out the value of the wine package. For example, we dined at Assiette, had the matched wines, which turned out to be 30ml pours! That worked out at 270ml of wine for about $55 per person, a price for which we could have bought a bottle each of our favourite wine on the list!! Whilst I would dine there again (the food was great) I would NEVER order their matched wines.

22-10-2007

hector said...

I think we are very fortunate to have all the choices we could possibly want in easy reach if you live in the major Australian cities. If you don't get what you pay for then you have just chosen badly ... and don't be worried about leaving a restaurant if it doesn't give you the right impression after you've arrived. Remember in Australia it's all about "The Vibe".

04-12-2007

Robert Coyle said...

I guess you firstly have to ask yourself why you are going to a restaurant. In most cases it's a reputation of greatness that you are chasing with attached "intangible" qualities. I beleive that when I go to a restaurant I like great service + great food + great beers/wines + ambience in style with the overall theme of the restaurant. If you get a combination of food and service I am happy to pay that little bit extra, but $1000 is a ridiculous amount per head.

When it boils down to it simple delicious food cooked with care and great service warrant a bit more from my back pocket. The attached status that increases the price is more likely to be feeding your ego than your senses. Sight, Smell, Taste & Texture (plus attentive service) is worth it's weight in gold and is worth those extra dollars!

14-03-2008

HelenMaguire said...

I do think we get what we pay for, it is our choice after all and if we want better service/food, then we have to dig deeper into our pockets.

17-05-2008

www.1001dinners.blogspot.com said...

In short sometimes. I've paid over $500/person quite often, it's easy in Europe and America and as a total experience I've considered it worthwhile about half the time. The value is not in the cost of food it's in the imagination, creativity, presentation, even the cutlery and crockery, service, ambience and physical situation. You can't eat the view but superb venues also have to be worth something.

09-07-2008

In order to post a reply, you need to be a Best Restaurants member. Please login with your details below. Not a member? Register now.

Email:
Password:  
Forgot your password?

<<<Back to Blogs   

de Groots Best Restaurants of Australia

 

de Groots Best Restaurants of Australia

This site is maintained by de Groots development team.